A broken toilet handle is a 5-minute fix that costs under $10.
What You’ll Need Replacement toilet handle kit.
Step 1: Remove the tank lid.
Step 2: Unhook the chain from the old handle arm inside the tank. Step 3: Unscrew the mounting nut — note it’s reverse threaded, turn clockwise to loosen.
Step 4: Insert new handle through the hole and tighten the nut counterclockwise.
Step 5: Attach the chain to the new handle arm and test.